Rooftop equipment installed without proper flashing is work that cut through a roof membrane and was sealed by somebody who was not a roofer. It is one of the most common findings on a commercial roof survey, and for a buyer it carries more weight than the leak it will eventually cause.
The reason is what it tells you. A building where every rooftop addition was flashed by a roofing contractor has been managed by somebody who understood that the roof is an assembly. A building where units sit on timber blocks with conduit taped to the membrane has not. That pattern predicts what the rest of the asset looks like, and it predicts the capital you will be spending in the first two years.
What to look for, and where
| Where to look | What a bad detail looks like |
|---|---|
| Mechanical units | Flat seals at deck level instead of a raised curb |
| Unit supports and sleepers | Timber or block set directly on the membrane |
| Electrical conduit | Laid across the field, strapped or taped down |
| Condensate lines | Discharging onto the membrane rather than into a drain |
| Satellite and antenna mounts | Fixed through the roof with sealant only |
| Grease and exhaust ducts | Staining spread around the penetration |
| Abandoned equipment | Units removed and the opening patched flat |
Abandoned penetrations are the ones most often missed. A unit taken out of service leaves an opening somebody closed quickly, and nobody inspects it afterwards because there is no longer any equipment there to service. The same applies to redundant supports, old cable trays and the pads left behind when a smaller unit replaced a larger one.
Why it matters more than the repair cost
The correction itself is usually modest: a proper curb or boot, the membrane turned up and terminated, a pitch pocket replaced with a manufactured detail. The consequences are not.
- Water enters at the penetration and travels. By the time a ceiling stain appears, the insulation around it is already wet, and wet insulation is replaced by area rather than by the point of entry.
- The warranty may no longer respond. An unauthorised alteration can put a system warranty out of force, which matters in a transaction because you paid for the remaining term. Void warranties covers how that is established.
- It travels with the permit history. Equipment added without a roofing contractor was frequently added without a permit either, which brings its own exposure. Unpermitted roof work sets out what a buyer inherits.
- It concentrates the next failure. Penetrations are where roofs leak. A field of improvised ones is a schedule of future leaks rather than one item.
What to ask for in diligence
- A roof survey that counts and photographs every penetration, not a sample. The count is the basis of any priced correction.
- The alteration and consent history, including tenant improvement approvals for any equipment serving a single tenancy.
- Permit records for rooftop mechanical and electrical work.
- The warranty certificate and the notified alteration list, then confirmation from the manufacturer that the warranty is in force.
- Service records for the rooftop units, which reveal how often somebody has been walking the roof and what they were walking on.
The document request checklist covers the full list, and a due diligence roof inspection is where the count and the photographs come from.
Turning the finding into a number
Price it as a unit rate times a count, add any membrane repair around penetrations that have already leaked, and add the moisture investigation where staining suggests water has been entering for some time. Keep that figure separate from the reroof reserve, because the two decisions are different: correction is immediate and cheap, replacement is deferred and expensive, and an immediate correction can extend the date of the second.
Where the count is high, the finding usually belongs in the negotiation rather than in the capital plan. Repricing a deal on the roof covers how a documented condition figure is used, and the red flags page sets this finding beside the two others that move budgets most.
Common questions
How can I tell a rooftop unit was installed without a proper flashing?
Look at how the penetration meets the membrane. A correctly built one has a raised curb or boot with the membrane turned up it and terminated mechanically. An improvised one is flat to the surface, sealed with mastic or sealant, and often shows repeated reapplication around the same joint.
- A raised curb or a manufactured boot indicates roofing work
- Mastic smeared at deck level indicates somebody else
- Multiple generations of sealant mean it has leaked before
- Conduit and condensate lines laid flat are a common sign
- Timber blocks under supports are rarely a roofing detail
The giveaway is usually the material rather than the workmanship. Roofers flash with the membrane system and terminate it. Mechanical and electrical trades seal with whatever is on the van, because their scope ended at the equipment. Photograph each penetration from directly above and from the side, because the side view is the one that shows whether anything was turned up and fixed, and that is the detail a surveyor will be asked about later.
Does a unit added after the roof was built void the roof warranty?
It can, and on a system warranty it frequently does. Manufacturer warranties normally require alterations to be carried out by an approved contractor and notified, so a penetration cut by another trade is an unauthorised alteration whether or not it has leaked.
- System warranties usually require approved contractor work
- Notification is often a condition as well as workmanship
- The effect can extend beyond the altered area
- A labour and material warranty is the most exposed
- The manufacturer decides, not the seller or the broker
Treat the warranty as unverified until the manufacturer confirms otherwise in writing. Ask the seller for the warranty certificate, the list of notified alterations and any inspection reports the manufacturer required, then ask the manufacturer directly whether the warranty is in force on the address. A certificate in a data room proves a warranty was issued, not that it still responds, and the difference is worth whatever remaining term you are paying for in the price.
Who is responsible for correcting a badly installed rooftop penetration?
Once you own the building, you are. Before closing it is a negotiable item like any other deferred condition, and the trade that created it is almost never available to pursue, because the work was done years ago by a subcontractor to a tenant or to a previous owner.
- The installing trade is rarely traceable or solvent
- A tenant improvement may put it in the lease history
- Before closing it is a price or an escrow question
- After closing it is a capital item on your schedule
- Correction cost is small next to the damage it prevents
The lease file is worth checking where units serve a single tenancy, because the obligation to maintain or restore may sit with the tenant rather than with the owner. That does not make the leak somebody else's problem in practice, but it changes who funds the correction and whether a restoration obligation exists at the end of the term. Ask for the alteration consents alongside the leases.
Should a buyer price the correction or ask the seller to do it?
Price it. Work done by a seller in the closing weeks is done to the cheapest specification that clears the item, by whoever is available, and inspected by nobody acting for you. A priced credit leaves you controlling the scope, the contractor and the timing.
- Seller repairs are scoped to close a point, not to last
- A credit lets you use your own roofing contractor
- Correction can be bundled with other roof work
- An escrow holdback suits larger or uncertain scopes
- Either way the figure needs a contractor quote behind it
Get the number from a roofing contractor rather than from the surveyor, and get it as a quantity and a unit price per penetration rather than as a lump sum, because the count often changes once somebody walks the whole roof properly. That structure also makes the figure defensible in a negotiation, since it is built from items the other side can see on the photographs.
Does solar on a commercial roof create the same problem?
Often a larger version of it. A solar array adds penetrations or ballast across the whole field, restricts access for inspection and repair, and introduces a second contract with its own removal cost. Whether it was installed by a roofing contractor is the first question.
- Attached systems multiply the number of penetrations
- Ballasted systems load the assembly instead
- Access for future repair is reduced across the array
- Removal and reinstatement cost belongs in the reserve
- The roof age under the array decides how urgent that is
The combination that causes trouble is a new array over a roof near the end of its life, because the replacement cannot happen without removing and reinstating the system. Establish the age of the covering beneath the panels, not just the age of the array, and carry the removal and reinstatement cost in the capital schedule alongside the reroof itself. Where the array is owned by a third party under a lease or a power agreement, read who bears that cost before you assume it is you.